Rallying for Real Elections…

Photo from AP

Running Scared in Malaysia

by John. R. Malott (original link here)

The Malaysian government has pulled out all the stops to prevent an opposition rally this weekend. This week, army units conducted crowd control exercises with banners that said, “Disperse or we will shoot!” The police set up roadblocks and arrested Malaysians simply for wearing yellow T-shirts, the signature color of Bersih, a coalition of 62 nongovernmental organizations that demands changes in Malaysia’s electoral system. To date, the police have arrested over 250 supporters of Bersih, claiming that they are “waging war against the king.”

Then something unprecedented happened. Malaysia’s King Tuanku Mizan Zainal Abidin, allegedly the target of Bersih’s campaign, intervened. He called on both Prime Minister Najib Razak and Bersih to resolve their differences in a spirit of harmony and cooperation, for the good of the nation.

There was a collective sigh of relief in Malaysia. The leader of Bersih, Ambiga Sreenevasan, an attorney and former president of the Malaysian Bar Council, met with the king and announced that the “Walk for Democracy,” as it was called, was cancelled. She said that she was ready to meet with the government to discuss Bersih’s concerns about electoral fairness. Prime Minister Najib then offered an olive branch, saying, “We are willing to provide a stadium for them to rally in … from morning until night,” an offer that Ms. Ambiga and Bersih immediately accepted.

Then Mr. Najib backed off. His government says that because Bersih is still illegal, it cannot apply for a permit. It also has banned Bersih’s leadership from entering Kuala Lumpur on the day of the rally. On Thursday, he joined a gathering of martial artists who said that their 50,000 members will “wage war” against Bersih. Donning their militant uniform, Mr. Najib said, “If there are evil enemies who want to attack the country from within, you, my brothers, will rise to fight them.”

Mr. Najib has undermined the authority of the king, who gave Bersih and its concerns credence by meeting with its leadership and calling for a negotiated solution. The political situation in Malaysia is a fast-moving target, and each day brings new developments. Ms. Ambiga and Bersih now say that because of Mr. Najib’s actions, they will go ahead with their assembly, no matter what.

Nobody knows what will happen tomorrow. Bersih’s main issue is not freedom of assembly but the fairness of Malaysia’s democratic process. Bersih’s backers ask how anyone can be opposed to free and fair elections.

It’s an easy question to answer. The United Malays National Organization, of which Mr. Najib is president, is the longest continuing ruling party in the world, and it is running scared.

In the last general election in 2008, Malaysia’s opposition took 47% of the popular vote. That year Parti Keadilan Rakyat, the party of Mr. Najib’s nemesis Anwar Ibrahim, went from one seat to 31. The establishment parties in Malaysia’s neighboring states are also in retreat. The opposition scored a major victory in Thailand last weekend, and in Singapore opposition candidates made surprising gains. No wonder Mr. Najib and company are worried.

Many observers of Malaysian politics believe that electoral reform will lead to the ruling party’s defeat, and that is why UMNO is afraid of Bersih. In the last election in 2008, the party received only one-third of the nation’s votes. UMNO rules only because of its coalition with other political parties, which it increasingly marginalizes, that represent the Chinese and Indian minorities.

Mr. Najib and his allies say that the opposition’s gains in 2008 prove that Malaysia’s elections are free and fair. Impartial observers disagree. Academic studies have enumerated how the Election Commission gerrymanders electoral districts to benefit the ruling party. The U.S. Department of State’s human rights report bluntly states that opposition parties are unable to compete on equal terms with the governing coalition because of restrictions on campaigning and freedom of assembly and association. “News of the opposition,” the U.S. says, is “tightly restricted and reported in a biased fashion.”

In the recent state elections in Sarawak, the government announced $390 million in local projects during the run-up to the polls. Prime Minister Najib was caught on video tape telling one village gathering that the government would give them 5 million ringgit ($1.5 million) for a local project on Monday, but only if they elected his candidate on Sunday.

Who would win elections in Malaysia that truly are free and fair? The U.S. State Department reports that despite the many election irregularities during the 2008 elections, “most observers concluded they did not substantially alter the results.” But unless the electoral reforms that Bersih is calling for are made, we will never know.

Despite the government’s intimidation, thousands of Malaysian citizens of all races and religions are expected to exercise their constitutional right to assemble and call for free and fair elections. Tomorrow’s protest represents a brave step in what not just Malaysians but also the international community should hope will begin the country’s transition to full democracy. Mr. Najib should display his own courage and ensure that a peaceful rally that seeks the fundamental rights of democratic peoples everywhere does not turn into a bloody confrontation.


Here are some excerpts reporting on the protest yesterday (9th July 2011):

Some factual reporting from the BBC:

Protesters who gathered in Kuala Lumpur were dispersed by police. Police in Malaysia have used tear gas and water cannons against thousands of people assembling for a banned protest in the capital Kuala Lumpur. Police say they arrested some 1,650 people before the rally was broken up.

Opposition activists called the protest to urge the government to implement electoral reform. The police threw up a cordon around central Kuala Lumpur from midnight on Friday, blocking major roads and suspending public transport. Riot police armed with batons confronted the thousands of people who had slipped through the security net, dispersing them with volleys of tear gas. Crowds around the city’s main bus station were also hosed down by water cannons.

Comments from an AFP article (via ST):

MALAYSIAN police may have crushed a weekend protest, but analysts say the crackdown has tainted the country’s democratic credentials and could embolden the opposition ahead of elections…

Prime Minister Najib Razak has been cultivating an image of an emerging nation with a strong economy and an open political environment. ‘I think it has tarnished Malaysia’s image and its membership in the UN Human Rights Council,’ said political analyst Khoo Kay Peng. Describing the police action as ‘completely overdone,’ Mr Khoo said, ‘It is a killer to our image as a progressive democratic country.’…

Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International condemned the crackdown and the arrests and chided Malaysia for flouting international standards. ‘As a current member of the UN Human Rights Council, the Malaysian government should be setting an example to other nations and promoting human rights,’ said Amnesty International’s Donna Guest.

And of course, comments from the Malaysian PM himself in The Star (via ST):

‘I hope the incident today (Saturday) will serve as a lesson for everyone that street demonstration not only brings hardship to the people, it could also lead to possessions being destroyed,’ he said after presenting prizes to the winners of the Bakti sports competition here on Saturday.

Mr Najib also said the so-called demand by Bersih protesters for a clean and fair election was merely to serve their ulterior motive. ‘Had the event turned serious, they would fully exploit it by giving an impression that Malaysia had no political stability with instances of police brutality.

‘Bersih supporters even changed their slogan to reformasi during the illegal rally, which is not at all related to their initial demand,’ he said. ‘It is proof that this illegal rally is politically-motivated and the demands for electoral reform are just an excuse for them to organise such rallies.’

And of course, who can forget the role of social media. Check this page out for some details on internet discourse surrounding Bersih 2.0.

What are your immediate reactions to the rally? Was the government and police response justified? 

Does it represent the misguided views of a few resentful civil society and opposition political groups? Or is it a credible protest for free and fair elections? 


One thought on “Rallying for Real Elections…

  1. As a Malaysian, I found that Bersih was a good opportunity for people to fight for free and fair elections and I supported this opposition rally. The government and police response was not justified as the people were having a peaceful protest. Before this, the King wanted this situation of unfair electoral processes to be resolved. The Prime Minister also agreed to “provide a stadium for them (protestors) to rally in … from morning until night.” However, this did not happen. In addition, the use of tear gas and water cannons have caused injuries to many people and even caused a death of one person. The poor handling of Bersih gives people the impression that the ruling party is weak. It also makes people think that the ruling party does not want to listen to the people’s opinions.

    This is a credible protest for free and fair election as the organizers genuinely wanted a peaceful protest. Unfortunately, the protestors started to retaliate when the police started to use tear gas and water cannons to disperse the crowd when no violence broke out initially. Evidences of corruption by the leaders in the ruling party have already cause citizens to vote against them. Forcefully dispersing the crowd is going to be detrimental for the ruling party as even more people will vote against them even if the opposition party may not be as efficient/effective.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s